اختبار بيان المشكلة

Here is my problem statement:
{{STATEMENT}}

The evidence I have:
{{EVIDENCE}}

Act as the most sceptical person in the room. In order:
1. Point out where the statement smuggles in a solution instead of describing a problem.
2. Name the assumption that, if wrong, makes the whole thing collapse.
3. Tell me which piece of evidence is weakest and what would actually settle it.
4. Rewrite the statement in one sentence, in the user's words rather than the company's.

Do not soften anything. If the statement holds up, say which part is strong and why.